Red Seal of approval

Avatar photo

My recent maiden voyage captaining an 18-wheeler convinced me that truck driving should be a Red Seal occupation.

The Red Seal program sets national standards for skills and knowledge within a particular trade. There are currently 54 Red Seal occupations in Canada, including auto mechanic, cook, plumber, electrician, and heavy equipment operator. When these tradespersons complete their apprenticeship and pass a standard exam, they receive a Red Seal endorsement on their trade certificate.

The Red Seal program promotes excellence while instilling pride in the occupation — two intangibles that unfortunately seem to be eroding in the driving profession.

Apparently, Alberta agrees with me. The province announced an apprenticeship-style model for truck drivers that’s scheduled to be implemented in nine short months.

It’s a fantastic idea. But sadly, the reality of truck driving becoming recognized as a skilled trade across Canada feels a long way off.

I don’t do it often, but I dusted off my Rolodex and polled 77 respected industry pros on three yes-or-no questions about the driving profession. There was a lot of agreement — and one shocking surprise.

Lots of support

Question #1: Would you support an apprenticeship-style program recognizing truck driving as a skilled trade? The response was unanimous: 77 yeses. That’s good news. Ottawa insiders I spoke with emphatically told me that truck driving won’t be recognized as a skilled trade unless there’s overwhelming industry support.

Put this one in the win column.

Safer roads

Question #2: Would apprenticeships for truck drivers help make roads safer?

Another slam dunk. 100% of respondents said yes.

Truckers have a fiduciary responsibility to the public. If the industry’s “powers that be” can show Ottawa and provincial regulators that common occupational standards for truck drivers would make roads safer, maybe they’ll help pay for it.

Gig slowdown?

Question #3: Would an apprenticeship model significantly reduce the number of Driver Inc. carriers?
88% of respondents said no.

I was dead wrong about this.

I thought Red Seal-style standards would put a big dent in Driver Inc. Instead of showing drivers how to pass a test, they’d have to develop real pros to a national standard.

Established fleets have been paying those bills for years, developing their own professional drivers.
I figured the added cost of using accredited drivers would make it harder for Driver Inc. fleets to operate. Guess not!

No downside

Besides cost, no one offered a shred of downside to setting occupational standards for truck drivers.
More spoke about the upside.

Certification would attract higher-level candidates. There would be less turnover and more respect for the profession. Safer roads would reduce insurance costs.

It would help our industry’s brand.

If I still owned trucks, I would salivate at the notion of apprentices striving to be future Red Seal professional drivers flying my banner.

Fragmentation challenges

There’s been a lot of talk about apprenticeships for truck drivers over the years. What’s holding us back today?

One of my concerns is that our industry is more fragmented than ever.

Our changing demographics mean no one voice speaks for most of the trucking industry. Gig carriers represent a growing percentage of fleets, and I doubt they’d sign on to any initiative that would significantly increase their costs.

These are big obstacles when you need overwhelming industry support to have any chance in Ottawa.

White knight

The white knight in all of this could be the Professional Truck Training Alliance of Canada (PTTAC). The PTTAC is Canada’s only national group representing commercial truck driver training businesses. 

Its objective is to make truck driving a Red Seal trade in Canada. I applaud its efforts. They are off to a great start, and I wish them the best of luck. They have their work cut out for them. But it sure looks like a lot of people are cheering for them.

Avatar photo

Mike McCarron is president of Rite Route Supply Chain Solutions and a partner in Left Lane Associates. You can reach Mike at mike@riteroute.ca


Have your say


This is a moderated forum. Comments will no longer be published unless they are accompanied by a first and last name and a verifiable email address. (Today's Trucking will not publish or share the email address.) Profane language and content deemed to be libelous, racist, or threatening in nature will not be published under any circumstances.

*

  • We need red Seal drivers for all cross border and hazmat loads in Canada
    I think Alberta is is correct to push red seal program
    I think a program to insure all drivers at all companies that pay by payroll hourly with a proper training program and the gov taking 1 cent per km driven of the carbon tax into a training program and 1 more cent into a program to insure small fleets under 100 power units owned to insure new drivers that are doing a term to get a red seal
    The Quality of some of the truck drivers has went downhill in the past 5 yrs
    I do not think driver Inc will be near as popular if red seal training is required and gov insurance like B C is available to all companies that pay their drivers on payroll with proper medical insurance if they cross the border

  • BC ran a pilot Red Seal program about 10 years ago that our school was part of. Program failed because carriers didn’t follow through on the experience portion that ran for 10 months. The overall program was 12 months. Carrier attitudes and viewpoints need to change for Red Seal to work There has to be buy in from HR, safety and dispatch to make it work and the apprentices need to be supported through out. On paper everyone thinks it’s great until there is a rush load to go somewhere and everything reverts to the normal “hurry up and get there”

    Any model that is developed needs to include a road map for the carriers to adopt internally for the finishing of the drivers. If the trainees are mixed in with the regular driver workforce for dispatch etc the system breaks down. Hopefully we can get there!

    • I have read this whole article through from top to bottom.
      I really think Andy has hit the nail on the head.
      Dispatchers and the Safety board’s definitely having to be onboard with all of this.
      Andys Quote on saying Loads is ready, hurry up and get it there, customers don’t understand that there really is a shortage in Professional Drivers.
      One more thought, we have and … can get drivers; Professional drivers are the ones that need to be recognized More, they already have that Red Seal Mentality.

  • Ontario had a voluntary apprenticeship that many Carrier’s and school grad’s benefited from. Once the tax credit dried up so did the interest in supporting it.
    There has never been better time for this industry to get behind the drive for red seal apprenticeship for commercial drivers.
    Thank you Mike for doing the survey with industry leaders.

  • It is crazy to think that a bad hair cut is more important than road safety! Yes, a hair dresser needs a red seal certification to cut hair, but a truck driver doesn’t! What is the worse thing that could happen if a hair dresser is improperly trained, someone will look silly for a few weeks. I poorly trained truck driver puts lives at danger. Our government needs to get it priorities straight.

  • Finally.

    I have been singing this song for a few decades.
    More education, more respect for all, more stability throughout the profession.
    Get rid of “low entry standards” that permits substandard staffing.
    Ultimately leading to more rounded compensation.

    Driver ink is generally presented as a path to higher income.
    Most of those involved, find the opposite.
    The real culprits are trucking companies working for substandard rates!

    Are there hurtles to overcome? Absolutely.
    Very much worth the effort.